Quick Setauket City NY MLS Search

Setauket City Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Setauket City and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Browse All Setauket City NY Properties for Sale

5 Beds 6 Baths 3481943 MLS
This stunning contemporary home boasts 5 bedrooms and 5 1/2 bathrooms, spanning an impressive 10,684 square feet. The home is designed to capture magnificent views from every level, with floor-to-ceiling windows that allow natural light to flood the living spaces. One of the home's standout features is its fully navigable dock, which offers 185 feet of waterfront access. The expansive dock is perfect for boating enthusiasts, and provides easy access to the water. Inside the home, the kitchen is a chef's dream, with granite countertops, stainless steel Sub Zero and Miele appliances, and Brazilian cherry cabinets. The floors are radiant heated for ultimate comfort, and the negative edge heated salt water pool si a true oasIs. The home is equipped with 800 amp service and a generator, ensuring uninterrupted power even during outages. The property also features a smart home system, central air conditioning, and a central vacuum system. Other notable features include a wine cellar, theater room, balcony, and 3 car garage. The home is built with structural steel and cinder block, and sits on 2.5 acres of land. Two Buderus boilers provide efficient heating throughout the home. In summary, this luxurious property offers a truly extraordinary living experience, with amenities and features too numerous to list. From its breathtaking views to its state-of- the-art systems, this contemporary home is truly one-of-a-kind.

183 Old Field Road, Setauket

6 Beds 7 Baths 3481194 MLS
We are offering a rare opportunity to complete the design of your very own private home on Old Field Road. This gated country estate spans almost 10,000 sq' on 2.5 acres with private beach access for your convenience. Some of the very unique features of the home include a 50' heated indoor lap pool complete with a dehumidifier, and a vaulted great room with a massive brick fireplace making family gatherings unforgettable. All of the mechanicals have been upgraded and the design work is all that's needed to complete the home whether you use the building materials on-site, or bring in your own. Nothing was spared regarding the completed work including reclaimed wood beams, Viking appliances, Pella windows, and a Generac Home Generator. We are showing the home by appointment only, and entertaining serious inquiries only. We have provided some virtual photos for your imagination and provided a list of completed work below. The hard part is done, all thats left is design. Documented $1.4m spent to date on renovations. 1. New roof plywood 5/8" double layer staggered with GAF 40-year architectural shingles. 2. Furnish and install larger custom enlarged Low E w/ Argon Roof Windows. 3. All new Oak Trim and Casing at new Roof Windows 4. All new Natural Gas line (156') and 1.5M BTU Commercial Size Meter. 5. All new two (2) gas-fired Burnham ALPINE 399,000/each btu boilers installed as Master and Slave with Commercial Expansion Tank. 6. Brand new 10 heat zone distribution and circulation pumps with new digital thermostats. 7. All new Wired NEST Fire/Smoke/Carbon Monoxide detectors throughout the house. 8. Whole house is pre-wired for CAT 5 and Video. 9. Brand new LED high hat 4" recessed lighting and switches. 10. Brand new Lurton child-proof electric receptacles. 11. All new (2) gas-fired NAVIEN Hot Water Heaters w/ timed circulating line to ensure hot water in 10-15 seconds anywhere in the house. 12. New hydronic cast iron baseboard radiators throughout the house. 13. New 50' indoor lap pool liner, security/safety cover, and Hayworth salt water system w/heated Zone. 14. 2 new 200-amp electrical service panels with all new breakers. (400-amp total) 15. New 32k whole house natural gas-powered Generac generator with Kohler upgraded transfer switch to handle HVAC loads. 16. Whole house Power Surge protection system (1 at each panel) with $50,000 equipment loss guarantee, 2 in total. 17. All new 5/8" Sheetrock throughout the entire house (1158 boards of 10' x 4') and level 5 skim coat. 18. All new double-layer plywood with new Burnt Oak plank-engineered flooring. 19. Added a heat zone w/ cast iron radiators and an independent thermostat in the 2-car garage. 20. Brand new $220k Custom Kitchen with a Cherry Island and all stone counters with a high backsplash. 21. New Great Room. 22. New HVAC system is installed. (In progress). 23. New connection to municipal water via Suffolk County Water Authority (368 feet) water main installed to house. Well water was deleted. 24. Brand new Fios Verizon fiber optic line installed from street to equipment in the basement. 6 routers for Wifi for complete indoor and outdoor coverage. 25. 5 of the 6 bathrooms have been (or are finishing the tiling stage) completely remodeled including new radiant low voltage floor heat, new walls, new floors, new insulation, all new plumbing, bath fans, electrical, Kohler designer fixtures and Porcelanosa bathroom tile. 26. Deer-fenced vegetable garden - organic soil beds.

190 Old Field Road, Setauket

6 Beds 5 Baths 3480608 MLS
Nestled within an idyllic neighborhood, this stunning diamond colonial home exudes elegance and charm. The exterior facade showcases a classic blend of timeless beauty and modern sophistication. As you approach the entrance, a meticulously manicured front yard and a charming pathway guide you towards the front door. The lush greenery and vibrant flowers add a touch of natural beauty, complementing the home's enchanting aura. In the wintertime enjoy the beautiful winter views. Stepping inside, you are greeted by a grand foyer adorned with gleaming hardwood floors and a cascading chandelier overhead. The spacious layout and high ceilings create an airy and welcoming atmosphere throughout the home. The main living area boasts an open concept design, seamlessly connecting the living room, dining area, and gourmet kitchen. Sunlight pours in through large windows, illuminating the space and highlighting the intricate architectural details. The kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring stainless steel appliances, custom cabinetry, and a central island creating a harmonious blend of style and functionality. Upstairs, this diamond colonial home offers a luxurious master suite. The master bedroom is a private retreat, complete with a spacious layout, and a cozy sitting area. The ensuite bathroom features a spa-like atmosphere. Upstairs also includes a second bedroom with a full bath, Additional bedrooms are generously sized and offer ample closet space, providing comfort and privacy for family members or guests. The outdoor area of the diamond colonial home is equally captivating, offering direct beach access. A serene backyard oasis awaits, featuring a spacious deck. Lush landscaping, mature trees, and a manicured lawn create a sense of tranquility and privacy. Overall, this diamond colonial home embodies a perfect blend of architectural excellence and contemporary, offering both comfort and refined living at its finest.

14 Tinker Bluff Court, Setauket

5 Beds 3 Baths 3471062 MLS
Welcome to Cedar Hills Estates, a private enclave exhibiting an assemblage of beautiful homes. 4 Cobbler Lane is no exception; fully renovated and impressive upon approach with a nod to traditional Victorian architecture plus all the goodness of modern day home. Stacked stone facade, Palladian windows, corner turret and wrap around porch all welcome you in. Once inside, the grand foyer soars two stories high, illuminated by a "tear drop" chandelier. Pass under the 2nd story balcony featuring wrought iron spindles, into the bright and airy living room with twin arched windows. Adjacent is an entertainers kitchen, fully renovated with custom cabinetry and hardware, massive center island, stunning pendants and herringbone backsplash. The space flows nicely into the banquet sized dining room. The great room offers a wood fireplace and outdoor access. A gorgeous laundry center, full bathroom and bedroom/office complete this level. Upstairs the dramatic overlook leads you to the primary suite with fireplace, dual walk in closets, stunning bathroom with floating double sink vanity, soaking tub and walk in shower, all accented with brushed gold hardware. There are three additional bedrooms, all with cathedral ceilings and huge closets, plus a full bathroom. The lower level is a walk out level of unfinished space with endless possibilities.Outside, the lush mature grounds, plus newly landscaped areas make the perfect sanctuary to relax on the front porch and enjoy all the peace and tranquility this property will bring.

4 Cobbler Lane, Setauket

6 Beds 5 Baths 3457848 MLS
This is your chance to live in beautiful Historic Setauket! This Gorgeous 6 Bedroom 4.5 Bath Two-Story Colonial near the water, has everything you are looking for and much more! As you enter the home, the Grand 2 Story Foyer leads you into the Formal Living Room w/ a Gas Fireplace. The oversized Formal Dining Room leads into the spacious Kitchen with Granite Countertops, Double Oven, and an Eat in Area with Sliding Doors to a Trex deck in the backyard. The Family Room is open to the Kitchen area & its ideal for entertaining. The Guest Bedroom w/ En-Suite Bath, and the Powder Room are also on the first floor! Second floor holds a Grand Master Suite with Tray Ceilings, En-Suite Bath w/ Jacuzzi Tub and oversized Shower, and 2 specious walk-in closets! Also on the 2nd floor, are 4 additional large Bedrooms, one w/ a walk-in closet!! These bedrooms share a Full Bath w/ Bathtub. The Laundry Room is also on the 2nd level. The Full Finished High-Ceiling Basement has a Wine Cellar, a Full Bath w/ Shower, and an Oversized Cedar Closet. The house has Central Vac, Central Water Filtration System, Central AC, Alarm System, House Generator, Natural Gas Heating, Hardwood Floors throughout, 3 Car Garage and so much more! The Beach and the Long Island Sound are just a short walk away and a perfect way to unwind and enjoy the beautiful outdoors. Deeded Beach and Mooring Rights for those who love water activities. This beautiful Colonial is near Schools, Shopping, Hospitals and the University. DON'T MISS OUT ON THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE THIS YOUR NEW HOME!!!

141 Main Street, Setauket

5 Beds 5 Baths H6216371 MLS
This beautiful 5,556 square foot Hamptons style, red cedar shingle home overlooks scenic Little Bay and is abutted by a wooded preserve. Designed by Michael Macrina Architect, and custom built by North Shore Home Design Inc. in 2013, this home boasts abundant natural light and spectacular sunrise views. Five bedrooms, four and a half baths with 9 and 10-foot ceilings throughout. The top floor, accessed by two sets of stairs, features a spacious primary suite with water views, a spa-like marble bathroom with a heated floor and an oversized jetted soaking tub, an adjoining art studio or nursery and large closets; 3 additional bedrooms, an exercise room, and an expansive billiard room with a vaulted ceiling. A cozy study with wainscoting and built-in shelving and storage is off the front entry, along with a spacious dining room. Rounding out the first floor is a spacious family room with a red brick wood-burning fireplace and coffered ceiling, a large guest room with an ensuite, a mud room and a laundry room. Hardwood oak flooring throughout. The vast entertaining space features a chef's dream gourmet kitchen with Subzero/Wolf appliances, including an eight burner dual fuel range, one hundred and forty-six bottle wine refrigerator, an under-the-counter ice maker, wet bar, granite countertops, beadboard ceiling, large pantry and custom cabinetry. Off the kitchen is an oversized rear porch with a built-in Wolf grill and beverage refrigerator overlooking the spectacular 40' x 20' heated gunite saltwater pool with red brick and bluestone surround. The spacious one-acre yard with ten zone irrigation system and mature plantings is meticulously maintained. Liquid propane gas heat with a whole-house standby generator. Two-car garage; additional detached one-and-a-half car garage, with ample storage space. This home is located in the Three Village Central School District.

28 Dyke Road, Setauket

Start Your Search

Information Copyright 2016, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.